| Samuel Henderson |
1847-1849 |
| Horatio C. Newcomb |
1849-1851 (resigned 11/7/1851) |
| Caleb Scudder |
1851-1854 |
| James McCready |
1854-1856 |
| Henry F. West |
1856 (died 11/8/56) |
| Charles G. Coulon |
Nov. 8-22, 1856 |
| William John Wallace |
1856-1858 (resigned 5/3/58) |
| Samuel D. Maxwell |
1858-1863 |
| John Caven |
1863-1867 |
| Daniel Macauley |
1867-1873 |
| James L. Mitchell |
1873-1875 |
| John Caven |
1875-1881 |
| Daniel W. Grubbs |
1881-1884 |
| John L. McMaster |
1884-1886 |
| Caleb S. Denny |
1886-1890 |
| Thomas L. Sullivan |
1890-1893 |
| Caleb S. Denny |
1893-1895 |
| Thomas Taggart |
1895-1901 |
| Charles A. Bookwalter |
1901-1903 |
| John W. Holtzman |
1903-1905 |
| Charles A. Bookwalter |
1906-1909 |
| Samuel Lewis Shank |
1910-1913 (resigned 11/28/13) |
| Henry R. Wallace |
Nov. 28, 1913 to Dec. 31, 1913 |
| Joseph E. Bell |
1914-1917 |
| Charles W. Jewett |
1918-1921 |
| Samuel L. Shank |
1922-1925 |
| John L. Duvall |
1926-1927 (resigned 10/27/27) |
| Claude E. Negley |
Oct. 27-Nov. 9, 1927 (appointed by City Council) |
| L. Ert Slack |
1927-1929 |
| Reginald H. Sullivan |
1930-1934 |
| John W. Kern |
1935-1937 (resigned 9/2/37) |
| Walter G. Boetcher |
1937-1938 |
| Reginald H. Sullivan |
1939-1942 |
| Robert Tyndall |
1943 to July 9, 1947 (died in office) |
| George L. Denny |
July 9, 1947 to Jan. 1, 1948 |
| Al G. Feeney |
1948 to Nov. 12, 1950 (died in office) |
| Phillip L. Bayt, Jr. |
Nov. 12, 1950-Nov. 24, 1951(resigned 11/24/51) |
| Christian J. Emhardt |
Nov. 24, 1951 to Jan. 1, 1952 |
| Alex M. Clark |
1952-1955 |
| Phillip L. Bayt, Jr. |
1956-1959 (resigned 1/1/59) |
| Charles Boswell |
1959-1962 (resigned 8/6/62 to become postmaster) |
| Albert H. Losche |
Aug 6, 1962 to Dec. 31, 1963 |
| John J. Barton |
1964-1967 |
| Richard G. Lugar |
1968-1975 |
| William H. Hudnut III |
1976-1991 |
| Stephen Goldsmith |
1992-1999 |
| Bart Peterson |
2000-2007 |
| Gregory A. Ballard |
2008-Present |
